Is There A Meaning in This Text > >
Home
Yahweh is a Warrior
Posted Monday, October 29, 2007 by Charlie Trimm
Categories:
Military Issues
This is another helpful introduction, this time as to how a pacifist can read the OT. Millard Lind, a Mennonite, sees the Exodus as the primary event in relation to war in the OT. The patriarchs are presented as peace loving people, so that means J was probably done during a time of weakness, such as the time of the Judges. The Exodus was a great and powerful act of God that influenced all the rest of history. The Israelites did not do anything, but simply trusted God, who worked a miracle and killed the Egyptians. This sets a pattern which Lind sees as foundational: God does the miracle, and the Israelites need only to trust him. When there is fighting, the fighting only occurs after the victory has already been won.
The kingship is the great downfall of Israel, since it involved (with David) the rise of standing army and "wise men," but declined to trust Yahweh like they used to. Daniel continues on the tradition as he should: Yahweh acts and his people trust, in contrast to the fighting Maccabees. Jesus also continues this tradition, in contrast to the zealots. The point for us today, although it is not stated as such, is that Christians should not fight, but only trust God, who will do a great act.
A central problem with the book is that Lind ignores texts that do not fit his thesis. A key text is the battle with the Amorite kings, which do not involve miracle, but are clearly pre-monarchic. He says that they are relevant to his point, but they seem to me to directly go against his point.
He assumes critical scholarship throughout the work (there is a foreword written by David Noel Freedman), although he does argue strongly for the historicity of the Exodus, since he sees that as historically foundational for Israel's view of war.
I appreciate much of what Lind argues for: God is indeed the divine warrior. But I don't see it solving as many problems. First, there are just too many battles where the Israelites do indeed fight. Second, even if God is the one doing the miracle, he is still killing people. As I read somewhere that I don't remember: regardless of who killed them, there are still dead Egyptians on the shore. Do pacifists serve a violent God?
Series: Book Reviews
The Gods of the Nations, by Daniel Block
Hebrew Poetry and Robert Alter
Creation According to Sailhamer
The Rise of Evangelicalism
Random book reviews from Charlie
Old Testament Theology Devotionals
The Dominance of Evangelicalism: The Age of Spurgeon and Moody
Rethinking Missions with Steve Saint
Neither Poverty nor Riches
The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind
The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind II
Going Places with God
A God Entranced Vision of All Things
The Meaning of Jesus: Borg versus Wright
Military History and Christianity: Do they mix?
Wright and Borg, Part 3
The Mosaic of Christian Belief
Cambridge Companion to Evangelical Theology
The Problem of War in the Old Testament
God is a Warrior
Holy War in Ancient Israel, by Gerhard von Rad
Yahweh is a Warrior
Is There A Meaning in This Text
Faithful Intepretation: Reading the Bible in a Postmodern World
Engaging Scripture
Does the Bible Justify Violence?
Reading Scripture with the Church
A History of Christian Thought, Volume 1
The Darker Side of Samuel, Saul and David
War in the Hebrew Bible: A Study in the Ethics of Violence
Golden Compass Trilogy
Israelite Religions, Richard Hess
The Mission of God
Biblical Interpretation: Then and Now
Life in Biblical Israel
Biblical Theology
Reading and Preaching the Bible in the Worship of the Church 3
Theological Introduction to the Psalms
The Tree of Life: An Exploration of Biblical Wisdom Literature
Login
to add comments
Navigation
Home
Login
Theoblogians
(
RSS
)
Adam Mattison
(
RSS
)
Brian Beers
(
RSS
)
Charlie Trimm
(
RSS
)
eric.mattison
(
RSS
)
Gerald Vreeland
(
RSS
)
Josh Michael
(
RSS
)
Michael Noland
(
RSS
)
Sam Yeiter
(
RSS
)
Recent Comments
Matthew
on
Bothering Jesus
Mark Adams
on
Arlen Chitwood and Soul Salvation
zach
on
Arlen Chitwood and Soul Salvation
jlepper
on
Arlen Chitwood and Soul Salvation
Brian
on
ETS Presentation
Popular Posts
Arlen Chitwood and Soul Salvation
Just War and Pacifism: The Problems
Of Umpires and Postmodernism
JP Moreland, the IFCA and Philosophy
Is God Manly
Is God Getting Older?
Bothering Jesus
Holy Matrimony?
How much is enough?
What Do We Have Here?
Blogroll
Ben Witherington
Between Two Worlds
Bibleplaces Blog
Biblical Horizons
Christian Cadre
Codex Blogspot
Come Up Hither
Dawn Treader
Evangelical Outpost
Evangelical Textual Criticism
InternetMonk
Jesus Creed
Magic Statistics
Strawberry-Rhubarb Theology
The Rebelution
Thinking Christian
Para-blog Pages
Bibleworks
Northwest Baptist Seminary
Distance Education at Trinity Evangelical
Wheaton College
Corban College
Evangelical Theological Society
Society Biblical Literature
Institute of Biblical Research
Pictures of Israel
Series of Posts
Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Book Reviews
ETS/IBR/SBL 2008
Inscriptions
Great Things Churches Do
Stupid Things Evangelicals Say
Justification According to NT Wright
ETS/IBR/SBL 2007
Bible Geography
Questions and Thoughts in Genesis
Archives
(3 Posts)
November 2008
(5 Posts)
October 2008
(4 Posts)
September 2008
(7 Posts)
August 2008
(9 Posts)
July 2008
(6 Posts)
June 2008
(13 Posts)
May 2008
(17 Posts)
April 2008
(14 Posts)
March 2008
(11 Posts)
February 2008
(11 Posts)
January 2008
(11 Posts)
December 2007
(12 Posts)
November 2007
(6 Posts)
October 2007
(6 Posts)
September 2007
(4 Posts)
August 2007
(11 Posts)
July 2007
(12 Posts)
June 2007
(14 Posts)
May 2007
(18 Posts)
April 2007
(15 Posts)
March 2007
(11 Posts)
February 2007
(11 Posts)
January 2007
(14 Posts)
December 2006
(8 Posts)
November 2006
(6 Posts)
October 2006
(11 Posts)
September 2006
(7 Posts)
August 2006
(10 Posts)
July 2006
(12 Posts)
June 2006
(10 Posts)
May 2006
(17 Posts)
April 2006
(11 Posts)
March 2006
(14 Posts)
February 2006
(16 Posts)
January 2006
(12 Posts)
December 2005
(10 Posts)
November 2005
(8 Posts)
October 2005
(10 Posts)
September 2005
(8 Posts)
August 2005
(10 Posts)
July 2005
(8 Posts)
June 2005
Categories
Bible (73)
Apologetics (1)
Theology (24)
Book Reviews (5)
Popular Culture (18)
Humor (11)
Culture and Theology (24)
Greek (3)
Bible Geography (5)
Leadership (1)
Faith (2)
Church (2)
Church History (15)
Missions (4)
Military Issues (18)
Hermeneutics (19)
Hebrew (1)
Old Testament Theology (8)
Psalms (5)
Jeremiah (1)
Theological Interpretation of Scripture (9)
Job (1)
Subscriptions
Subscribe to Theoblogian
Other Stuff
My Ecosystem Details